We support several k12 networks. Looking to refresh ~400 access switches in the next 2-3 years.
We have narrowed vendors to Cisco and HPE/Aruba.
Core requirements are:
- 1Gb access
- PoE+ w/ ~700w power budget
- At least 2 SFP+ uplinks
Thanks to changes in E-Rate funding models, cost is now more a factor than previous refreshes.
Looks like the Aruba 2930F (JL256A) and Catalyst 9200 (C9200L-48P-4X-EDU) fit the requirements.
I like Cisco because we run 95% Cisco already -- our training is current and things work well. But, they came up about 30% more expensive. I like HPE/Aruba because they will natively integrate with our WLAN/NAC, and I like AirWave's provisioning features. Also cheaper. But they would come with a modest learning curve.
Interested in feedback from those who have or plan to refresh their access layer, especially in K12, or when budget has been a constraining factor. Thoughts?
No comments:
Post a Comment